Madlyn’s friends’ dislike of Colby was apparent when “The Ultimatum” contestant introduced her pals to her trial marriage partner, Randall (via Netflix). Over drinks and dinner, Madlyn introduced Randall to three of her closest friends: Maeson, Karli, and Caila. When Colby’s name is first brought up in the conversation, Madlyn’s friends share their disapproval of Madlyn’s boyfriend. “He just wants to be the center of attention,” shared Maeson, as the two other friends echoed their agreement.
In a confessional, Maeson revealed that she and Colby had hooked up in college. “Wasn’t really something rememberable,” she admitted. “On an attractive level, I definitely think Randall would be a better lover.” Maeson even went so far as to say, if she was in Madlyn’s shoes, she would make a move on Randall.
Maeson wasn’t the only friend hoping that “The Ultimatum” may lead to a break-up between Colby and her best friend. When Randall asked the girls what their concerns were about Madlyn joining the show, Karli revealed that she was “hopeful.” “I just don’t know if he’s on the same level as you, like maturity-wise,” she admitted, comparing Randall to Colby. By the end of the interaction, Madlyn’s friends were very much Team Randall. Sorry, Colby.